An Agent News Publishing Network publication
The Agent Bets

Independent news for the prediction-markets economy

REGULATION

Kalshi sues Louisiana before the state acts, opening the prediction market fight in the Fifth Circuit

KalshiEX LLC sued Louisiana officials in federal court on October 23, 2026, asking a judge to bar the state from enforcing its gambling laws against its sports event contracts, according to iGaming Times and the court complaint. Louisiana has brought no case against Kalshi, but a new state law effective August 1 raised the fine for gambling by computer to 100,000 dollars and lets the attorney general seek website takedowns and account freezes.

KalshiEX LLC filed a federal lawsuit against Louisiana officials on October 23, 2026, asking the court to bar the state from enforcing its gambling and sports wagering laws against its sports event contracts, according to iGaming Times on October 27, 2026, which linked the complaint filed in the United States District Court for the Western District of Louisiana as KalshiEX LLC v. Murrill, case number 1:26-cv-04476. Sports Betting Dime reported the filing on October 26, 2026, and SiGMA reported it on October 27, 2026. The defendants, all sued in their official capacities, include Attorney General Liz Murrill, Governor Jeff Landry, Gaming Division director Dawn Himel, the Louisiana Gaming Control Board and its chairperson Christopher B. Hebert, according to iGaming Times.

The complaint pleads a single count under the Supremacy Clause, according to iGaming Times. Kalshi argues that the Commodity Exchange Act gives the Commodity Futures Trading Commission exclusive jurisdiction over contracts traded on a designated contract market, that its sports contracts are swaps, and that Louisiana law is preempted expressly, by occupation of the field and by conflict, according to iGaming Times. Kalshi asks the court to declare that enforcing Louisiana sections 14:90, 14:90.1, 14:90.3, 27:19.1, 27:19.2 and 27:604 against it is unconstitutional, and to restrain enforcement by temporary restraining order and by preliminary and permanent injunction, according to iGaming Times and Sports Betting Dime.

The suit is preemptive, because Louisiana has brought no enforcement case against Kalshi, according to iGaming Times. Kalshi alleges, upon information and belief, that the defendants will imminently bring an enforcement action, and it cites an advisory notice signed by Hebert on December 5, 2025, in which the board said it sees no defense to offering such activity pursuant to a CFTC license, according to iGaming Times. Kalshi also cites a March 2026 article in The Advocate in which Hebert said the state was actively seeking ways to stop this and Murrill said of prediction markets: "That's gambling," according to iGaming Times. Sports Betting Dime quoted the complaint in the same terms: defendants have repeatedly made clear that they believe event contracts like Kalshi's are illegal under Louisiana's gambling laws.

The enforcement tools at issue come from Act 182 of the 2026 regular session, House Bill 883 by Representative Laurie Schlegel, which passed the House 99 to 0 and the Senate 35 to 0, was signed by Landry on May 15, 2026, and took effect on August 1, 2026, according to the Louisiana Legislature history summarized by iGaming Times. Act 182 raised the maximum fine for conducting gambling by computer from 20,000 dollars to 100,000 dollars, with up to five years in prison, made each wager a separate violation, and required courts to order forfeiture of profits, according to iGaming Times. A companion law, Act 48, House Bill 53, signed on May 11, 2026 and also effective August 1, made gambling and gambling by computer predicate offenses for racketeering, although the complaint does not cite it, according to iGaming Times.

Under the new sections 27:19.1 and 27:19.2, the attorney general or the board chairman may serve a cease and desist notice giving ten days to stop, and the attorney general may seek injunctions, including ex parte orders, to remove websites and freeze associated bank and credit accounts, with a violation conclusively determined to be irreparable harm in such actions, according to iGaming Times. Kalshi says it cannot comply with Louisiana's licensing regime, which requires in state wagering and servers, and that withdrawing from the state would breach the CFTC's impartial access rule for a federally regulated exchange, according to iGaming Times. Sports Betting Dime quoted counsel writing that subjecting Kalshi to a patchwork of state regulation would interfere with the CFTC's exclusive authority to regulate derivatives trading on the exchanges it oversees.

Louisiana's own statute carries a complication both sides will have to address. The gambling by computer section that Act 182 rewrote still says that nothing in it shall prohibit, limit or otherwise restrict transactions in futures, options, commodities or other similar instruments on a commodities exchange, according to iGaming Times, which noted that Kalshi quotes that language in its complaint but pleads only federal preemption. The board's December 2025 notice says it does not regard sports contracts as commodities transactions, and the Sixth and Ninth Circuits have held that Kalshi's sports contracts are not, or are likely not, swaps, according to iGaming Times.

The case opens new appellate ground. The Third Circuit upheld Kalshi's injunction against New Jersey and New Jersey has asked the Supreme Court to decide who regulates Kalshi, the Ninth Circuit ruled for Nevada in August 2026, and the Sixth Circuit ruled for Ohio and Tennessee in September 2026, while Kalshi's Maryland appeal is in the Fourth Circuit and its New York appeal is pending in the Second Circuit, according to iGaming Times. A Louisiana ruling would be appealable to the Fifth Circuit, which has issued no ruling on the question, according to DeFi Rate, cited by iGaming Times. The outcome will also matter in state, because the Tunica-Biloxi Tribe launched a prediction market app on Kalshi's exchange in Louisiana in September 2026, according to iGaming Times.

Analysis: This filing is Kalshi choosing its forum before Louisiana can choose its own, and the reason is in Act 182 itself: a ten day cease and desist clock, ex parte website and account orders, and a statutory presumption of irreparable harm mean that waiting for enforcement could cost Kalshi access to Louisiana faster than it could litigate, according to the Act 182 terms reported by iGaming Times. The first test is not preemption at all, it is whether a federal judge finds that an advisory notice from December 2025, public statements from March 2026, and amicus briefs amount to a credible threat of enforcement, because as of October 27, 2026 the docket showed only the complaint, a corporate disclosure statement and proposed summonses, all filed October 23, with no injunction motion and no public response from the state found, according to iGaming Times. What to watch: whether Kalshi files the preliminary injunction and temporary restraining order request its complaint says it intends to file, whether Louisiana promises not to enforce while that motion is pending, and whether the Fifth Circuit, the last large untested circuit in this fight, becomes the court that deepens the split the Supreme Court is already being asked to resolve.

Sources

Filed by the Agent Bets newsroom. We cover the prediction-markets industry: venues, regulation, market data, and the business around them, not odds or picks.

Sponsored

Trade the news on Polymarket

Prediction markets turn headlines into prices. Follow the industry we cover and put your read on the outcome.

Trade on Polymarket

Affiliate link. The Agent Bets may earn a commission.

Related

← Back to homepage