The Commodity Futures Trading Commission issued an interpretation on November 5, 2026 telling designated contract markets to cease domestic geographic restrictions that violate its Impartial Access Requirements within 30 days, or else submit an explanation to the Division of Market Oversight for why such compliance is not feasible, according to CFTC Release 9323-26 on November 5, 2026. The interpretation construes Commission Regulation 38.151(b), which requires designated contract markets to provide competitive, open, fair and impartial access to their members and persons with trading privileges, according to the CFTC on November 5, 2026.
"Derivatives markets must operate on a uniform basis at a national scale in order to achieve the purposes set out in the Commodity Exchange Act," Chairman Michael S. Selig said in CFTC Release 9323-26 on November 5, 2026. "Geographic access restrictions are inconsistent with those purposes and the Act's impartial access requirements," Selig said, according to the CFTC on November 5, 2026. The release names no exchange, no state and no platform, according to ValueWalk on November 5, 2026, and the Commission said it will consider the facts and circumstances of any particular case in connection with potential Commission action, according to the CFTC on November 5, 2026.
In the interpretive guidance published with the release, the Commission said it is aware that some exchanges have adopted criteria restricting access to certain event contract markets based on a prospective trader's location or residence, according to RG.org on November 6, 2026. The guidance, approved subject to pre-publication technical corrections, states that the Commodity Exchange Act and Commission regulations generally do not permit a designated contract market to limit access based on the location of an otherwise eligible market participant within the United States, according to RG.org on November 6, 2026.
The clock also reaches intermediaries. Within 30 days, designated contract markets should ensure that intermediaries accessing their markets are not impeding and are complying with the Impartial Access Requirements, or else submit an explanation to the Division of Market Oversight, according to the CFTC on November 5, 2026. FanDuel and Fanatics primarily operate as intermediaries in event contracts, according to InGame on November 5, 2026, and DraftKings, Fanatics and FanDuel all restrict access to sports event contracts in states where they hold sportsbook licenses, as state gaming commissions have threatened to revoke the licenses of operators that offer such contracts in their states, according to InGame on November 5, 2026.
The interpretation reverses the practical position exchanges have traded under. The CFTC had not previously interpreted the impartial access principle to refer to geographic access across the United States, which allowed prediction markets to geofence their sports offerings from states where courts determined they were offering illegal gambling, according to InGame on November 5, 2026. Kalshi's sports contracts have been banned by court orders in Michigan, Nevada and Washington, and the company pulled the contracts from Utah after the state brought criminal charges, according to InGame on November 5, 2026. In Michigan, a September 2026 preliminary injunction ordered Kalshi to prevent residents from accessing sports event contracts using state approved geolocation technology, with potential penalties of $500,000 per day for violations, according to NextPredict on November 6, 2026.
Courts had rejected the argument the CFTC has now adopted. In August 2026, the Ninth Circuit ruled against Kalshi in its Nevada dispute, rejecting the claim that blocking Nevada residents would violate impartial access requirements and describing Kalshi's position as a "false, all-or-nothing proposition," according to NextPredict on November 6, 2026. The Sixth Circuit reached a similar conclusion in September 2026 in cases involving Ohio and Tennessee, and a federal judge in New York rejected the argument in July 2026, according to NextPredict on November 6, 2026. Thursday's guidance takes the opposite position on geographic access, explicitly stating that such restrictions are inconsistent with federal law, according to NextPredict on November 6, 2026.
The guidance rests on a liquidity claim and stops short of resolving the conflict it creates. State by state restrictions can leave traders unable to manage positions if they travel, fragment liquidity and weaken price discovery, according to RG.org on November 6, 2026, and the guidance says election markets may be particularly sensitive because the most informed trading may come from residents of the state holding the election, according to RG.org on November 6, 2026. The guidance does not itself overturn court orders, and affected exchanges would still need judicial relief before disregarding them, according to NextPredict on November 6, 2026. A Kalshi spokesperson told InGame on November 5, 2026 that the company is evaluating the new guidance.
Analysis: The 30 day window that began on November 5, 2026 runs to December 5, 2026, and the comply or explain filings are where this interpretation becomes concrete. An exchange that blocks a state under a court injunction, like the preliminary injunction a federal judge granted on November 4, 2026 barring Kalshi sports contracts on two California tribes' lands, according to SBC Americas on November 6, 2026, has a different explanation to give the Division of Market Oversight than an operator that blocks a state voluntarily to protect a sportsbook license. What to watch: which exchanges file explanations and on what grounds, whether any exchange cites the guidance in court to seek relief from an existing injunction, and whether the Commission acts on an explanation it finds unpersuasive, because the release reserves case by case judgment rather than promising enforcement, according to the CFTC on November 5, 2026. A separate CFTC rule excluding licensed sportsbook wagers from the swap definition, with comments due November 18, 2026, according to RG.org on November 6, 2026, will show whether the agency is drawing the same national uniformity line in its rulemaking as in this interpretation.